Community trumps crime at Tokai Park

Perceptions unable to mug the facts

SANParks staff are conservationists – they’re not crime fighters. Where are the police? Where are the private security contractors who are adept at operating on the urban fringes of the mountain where most of these infringements occur? We need to utilise the neighbourhood watches [they are our eyes and ears]. We have hundreds of hikers on the mountain at any point in time. Use them.

Tokai Park, an integral part of Table Mountain National Park, lies immediately adjacent to the City of Cape Town. It is certainly no stranger to crime. We therefore urge all recreational users of Tokai Park to remain as alert to criminal activity as they would elsewhere in the city.

That stated – and stressed, it is essential that our approach to crime remains grounded in fact. Avoiding our pristine natural areas because of perceived, rather than real, threats would be counterproductive. We and our many hundreds of thousands of visitors reap immeasurable rewards immersing ourselves in the natural beauty about us.

Statistics on crime in the Tokai neighbourhood from a local police station show that one or two house break-ins are reported monthly. More reports of trespass and theft from motor vehicles are received. Lower Tokai Park, with two incidents reported since 2016, is orders of magnitude safer than its surrounding suburbs.

Even so, one of the incidents, the horrific rape and murder of 16-year-old Franziska Blöchliger in 2016, should serve as a reminder that we are nowhere exempt the shocking reality of violent crime in South Africa. Franziska’s death, as well as those of two young cousins killed by a falling pine at Tokai Park in 2002, will not – and should not – easily be forgotten.

It is a fact that some populist groups hold that, owing to its density, reintroduced Fynbos is responsible for whatever crime there is at Tokai Park. However, Friends of Tokai Park maintains that criminal activity cannot be tied to vegetation type and we will not allow alarmists to abuse tragic events to promote, in this instance, the retention of pine trees at Tokai Park. Such abuses of tragedy are themselves criminal.

Scientific research shows no evidence linking Fynbos to criminal activity. In an article reporting insights from Cape Town, the researchers state:

“We argue that the incidence of crime may not always be determined by the biogeographical status of dominant plants (i.e., whether vegetation is dominated by native, alien, or invasive alien species).”

To keep yourself constantly abreast of recent criminal incidents at Tokai Park and elsewhere in Table Mountain National Park, consult André Colling’s most excellent, regularly updated Table Mountain Crime Map.

In as much as pretending Fynbos leads to crime at Tokai Park is itself a crime, lending credence to the notion that Tokai Park has a “crime problem” of similar proportions to its suburban surrounds would be as criminal.

Nonetheless, the ugly reality of attacks, muggings and theft on the periphery and, occasionally, deep within the Park, means that we would be neglecting our and others’ safety were we not always to bear SANParks’ safety tips in mind. To avoid becoming a victim of crime, please take the following listed precautions:

  • Try not to walk/jog/cycle/horse-ride alone; four is the ideal number.
  • Let someone know when to expect your return (family or friends).
  • Stick to well-used and marked paths, which will be indicated on the Park’s hiking map and read the warnings on this map. Don’t take shortcuts.
  • Take a fully-charged cell phone. Some parts of the Park do not have cell phone reception, but you will always be able to reach a place where you can use a cell phone more quickly than you’ll get to a landline.
  • Do not attract unwanted attention by openly displaying cash, cameras or other valuables.
  • If you are confronted by a criminal, don’t resist. Hand over your goods as resistance might incite a mugger to violence.
  • Program emergency numbers in your cell phone before your walk.

Current hotspots include parts of Table Mountain National Park’s Northern Section – around the City Bowl and its eastern flank – and the Southern Section – at Red Hill (Kleinplaas Dam and its immediate surrounds). Please be cautious.

Table Mountain Safety Forum

The Western Cape Government convenes the Table Mountain Safety Forum to ensure the optimal use of its crime-fighting resources in conjunction with other statutory bodies and agencies, private companies and community-based organisations.

The TMSF meets at the Department of Community Safety (5th Floor, 35 Wale Street, Cape Town) at 10 AM on the first Tuesday of each month. It comprises senior representatives from:

South African National Parks (SANParks)
South African Police Services (SAPS)
the Western Cape Government
the City of Cape Town and its law enforcement affiliates
the Central City Improvement District
Cape Town Tourism, and…
user and interest groups including the Pedal Power Association, the Hikers Network and Table Mountain Watch

The forum focuses on:

  • managing incidents and data analysis
  • encouraging volunteerism
  • effective communication
  • victim support services
  • the use of technology to complement existing operations
  • community involvement through neighbourhood watches and Community Police Forums (CPF), and
  • monitoring and evaluation

2019 crime stats for Tokai Park

Vigilance overcomes villainy

Phew...! I'm no sissy and I'm very aware of my surroundings and try to stay out of danger but, today, I came close to being mugged for my cellphone in Lower Tokai Park. No, not in the Fynbos, but in the open...on the path alongside the pines and the horse arena. Anyway, I sent a quick "I'm in trouble" message...and then got myself out the park and to the home of a friend in Dennedal Rd. Frantically rang the bell and luckily [he] opened up for me, just as the dodgy folk got close. Very stupid of me to have my cellphone visible. Will never do that again.

CrimeStatsSA tells us that Kirstenhof, the SAPS precinct into which Tokai Park falls, recorded seven murders in 2019 (following one in 2018 and four the previous year).

The neighbouring Diep River, Hout Bay, Fish Hoek and Muizenberg precincts (into whose jurisdiction Table Mountain National Park falls), recorded 1, 20, 0 and 51 murders respectively. Of the 72 murders recorded in this small area, one was, sadly, a Ukrainian visitor in the vicity of the East Fort in Hout Bay.

The South African Mountain Accidents Database (SAMA) records two criminal fatalities across the Peninsula for the same period. It reports a total of 26 criminal incidents, of which 15 occurred in the second half of the year.

Steenberg, a far smaller SAPS precinct bordering Kirstenhof, recorded 53 murders during 2019. Given these alarming figures and perspective of life outside Table Mountain National Park, is it reasonable to insist that SAPS, SANParks or any other law-enforcement agency allocates further limited resources to our National Park?

Our private-sector and community-led crime-fighting initiatives appear to be doing more than holding their own. This is borne out by the South African Mountain Accidents (SAMA) database recording a remarkably low 26 incidents across the Peninsula for 2019 compared to the 56 recorded during 2018. However, as was the case in 2018, two of 2019’s incidents proved fatal.

Note: The South African Mountain Accidents Database is a project managed by the Mountain Club of South Africa’s Search and Rescue division. It is run by Andrew Lewis. The MCSA Emergencies page is an excellent resource.

The Kirstenhof SAPS precinct (clear), into which Tokai Park falls
Criminal incidents across the Peninsula (TMNP) through 2018
Criminal incidents peninsula wide. A 2018/9 comparison.

EMERGENCY NUMBERS

  • CT Emergency Services: (021) 480 7700 Toll free: 112 (or 107 from a landline)
  • SAPS (South African Police Service): 10111 (021-10111 on a mobile)
  • TMNP Hotline: 086 110 6417
  • Ambulance: 10177
  • Mountain Rescue Services: (021) 948 9900
  • MCSA Search and Rescue: (021) 937 0300
Security companies that will assist you if possible:
  • Mountain Men (patrols the mountain between Newlands and Fish Hoek): 086 107 0000
  • ADT Emergency (anywhere in the Western Cape): 086 121 2301

Fire

Maintaining one's defensible space on the urban edge is as sensible in the Fynbos Biome as elsewhere

Fire

Maintaining one's defensible space on the urban edge is as sensible in the Fynbos Biome as elsewhere
let's roll

Trees

Injuries and fatalities caused by 'widow makers' or diseased trees pose a continuing threat to safety

Trees

Injuries and fatalities caused by 'widow makers' or diseased trees pose a continuing threat to safety
take me there

Safety

A three-tier, facts-based approach to safety is needed for Tokai Park and Table Mountain National Park

Safety

A three-tier, facts-based approach to safety is needed for Tokai Park and Table Mountain National Park
Okay, tell me more